Helical Piles vs Sonotubes: Which Is Better for Your Deck?

Helical piles and sonotube concrete footings both support decks. Here is how they compare on install time, soil, weather and mess.
Helical piles installed for a backyard deck foundation in Toronto

Short answer: For most Toronto decks, helical piles are the faster, cleaner and more predictable footing. They install in hours, can carry load the same day, and reach below the frost line with almost no digging. Sonotubes (poured concrete piers) are still a reliable choice when access is easy, the soil is firm and you don’t mind the extra time for digging and curing. The right answer depends on your soil, access, deck height and schedule, which is why we look at the site before recommending either.

Every deck in Toronto sits on footings, and those footings decide whether the deck stays level for twenty years or starts to heave, sag and pull away from the house after a few winters. The two most common options are helical piles (also called screw piles) and sonotube concrete footings. Both can meet the Ontario Building Code when they are installed correctly. They just get there in very different ways.

This guide explains how each footing works, how they compare on strength, speed, mess and long-term performance in Toronto’s clay soil and freeze-thaw winters, and how to decide which one fits your project.

Concrete deck footings poured before framing
Concrete sonotube footings poured below the frost line before framing.

What is a sonotube footing?

“Sonotube” is a brand name that has become the everyday word for a round cardboard form used to pour a concrete pier. The installer digs a hole, usually with an auger or by hand, down below the local frost line. In the Toronto area that is generally about 4 feet (1.2 m). The tube goes into the hole, concrete is poured inside, and a metal bracket or anchor bolt is set in the top to connect the deck post.

Many sonotube footings also have a wider base, either a poured pad or a plastic “bigfoot” style form, so the load spreads over more soil. That bearing area matters, because a concrete pier only holds what the soil underneath it can support.

How a sonotube footing is installed

  1. Call for utility locates and mark the footing positions.
  2. Dig each hole to below frost depth (by hand, auger or mini excavator).
  3. Set and level the tube and base form, then backfill around it.
  4. Mix and pour concrete, setting the post anchor in the top.
  5. Wait for the concrete to cure before loading it (typically several days).
  6. Remove or haul away the excavated soil.

What is a helical pile?

A helical pile is a galvanized steel shaft with one or more helix-shaped plates welded near the tip. Instead of digging a hole, the installer screws the pile into the ground with a hydraulic drive head, much like driving a large screw into wood. The helix plates pull the shaft down and lock into the soil below the frost line.

As the pile goes in, the installer watches the installation torque. Torque is closely related to how much load the pile can carry, so it gives a real-time check on capacity that a concrete pier can’t offer. Once the target depth and torque are reached, the pile is cut to height and capped with a bracket, and the deck framing can start right away.

How a helical pile is installed

  1. Call for utility locates and lay out pile positions.
  2. Screw each pile in with a compact machine or hand-held driver.
  3. Monitor torque and depth until the pile reaches competent soil below frost.
  4. Cut to height, level and attach the post bracket.
  5. Start framing the same day. No curing, no spoil piles.

Why Toronto’s soil and frost change the decision

Much of Toronto and the GTA sits on clay and silty clay soils. Clay holds water, swells when wet and shrinks when dry, and it is very prone to frost heave: water in the soil freezes, expands and lifts anything that isn’t anchored deep enough. Footings that are too shallow, too short, or that have a smooth surface the frozen soil can grip are the ones that push up over the winter.

Both footing types deal with frost by going below the frost line. The difference is how they resist the uplift from the frozen layer above:

  • Sonotubes rely on depth, the weight of the concrete and a wide base. If the hole is too shallow, the base too small, or the sides of the pier rough and flared near the top, frost can grab the pier and lift it.
  • Helical piles have helix plates locked into undisturbed soil below the frost zone. The plates act as an anchor, so the pile resists both downward load and upward heave. That makes them a strong fit for clay, wet ground and areas with a high water table.
Helical piles installed for a backyard deck foundation in Toronto
Helical piles installed for a backyard deck foundation in Toronto.

Helical piles vs sonotubes: side-by-side comparison

FactorHelical pilesSonotube footings
Installation timeUsually a few hours for a typical deckUsually one to several days, plus curing
Ready to build onSame dayAfter the concrete cures
Digging and soil removalNone. No spoil piles to haul awayEvery hole is excavated and the soil has to go somewhere
Lawn and landscape damageMinimalModerate to heavy around each hole
Capacity checkMeasured on site through installation torqueAssumed from hole depth, base size and soil
Frost heave resistanceExcellent. Helix plates anchor below frostGood when deep enough with a proper base
Wet ground or high water tableWorks wellHoles can flood or collapse before the pour
Winter installationPossible in most conditionsDifficult. Concrete needs protection from freezing
Tight or hard-to-reach backyardsCompact equipment fits through gatesHand digging is slow. Concrete has to be carried in
CostDepends on number of piles, depth and accessDepends on number of footings, digging and disposal

When helical piles make more sense

  • You want the deck built fast. Footings in the morning, framing in the afternoon.
  • Your soil is clay, wet or soft. Helix plates find bearing in deeper, firmer soil and resist heave.
  • Access is tight. Narrow side yards, gates and finished landscaping are much easier with compact pile equipment.
  • You’re building close to the house. No large holes beside your foundation and no risk of undermining it.
  • It’s late fall or winter. Piles can go in when concrete work would need heating and protection.
  • You may add load later. Hot tubs, roofs, pergolas and screened rooms need footings sized for the extra weight. Piles can be selected for it from the start.

When sonotubes are still a good choice

  • The site is open, dry and easy to dig, with firm native soil.
  • The deck is small, low and has only a few footings.
  • The schedule is flexible and a few days of curing time isn’t a problem.
  • The homeowner or builder strongly prefers concrete, and the design drawings are already based on it.

Our honest view: a well-built sonotube footing is perfectly sound. Most of the problems we see with concrete piers come from installation shortcuts, like holes that are too shallow, no base, or poor backfill, not from concrete itself.

What decides the cost of each option

We don’t quote prices online because every yard is different, but these are the factors that drive the cost of a footing package:

  • Number of footings and the deck layout
  • Required depth and soil conditions
  • Access for equipment (open yard vs narrow gate)
  • Soil disposal and site restoration for dug footings
  • Design loads, such as a hot tub, roof or second level
  • Permit and engineering requirements

For a clear number for your project, contact us for a free site assessment.

Permits, inspections and the Ontario Building Code

Most raised or attached decks in Toronto need a building permit, and the footings are part of what gets reviewed and inspected. With sonotubes, the inspector usually checks the holes before the pour. With helical piles, the city typically wants the pile product details and installation records, and for some projects an engineer’s letter. We provide installation records with our piles so your permit file is complete. For details on permits, read our guide Do You Need a Permit to Build a Deck in Toronto?

Frequently asked questions

Are helical piles stronger than concrete footings?

They can be, but “stronger” depends on design. A correctly sized helical pile installed to the right torque will typically carry more than a typical deck sonotube in the same soil, and it has the added benefit of resisting uplift. The key advantage is that its capacity is verified during installation.

How long do helical piles last?

Hot-dip galvanized steel piles are designed for long service lives in typical soils, often quoted as many decades. Corrosion rate depends on soil chemistry and moisture, which is why galvanizing and proper pile selection matter.

How deep do deck footings need to go in Toronto?

Footings need to reach below the frost line, which in the Toronto area is generally around 4 feet (1.2 m). Helical piles often go deeper than that until they reach the required torque in firm soil.

Can I put helical piles under an existing deck?

Often yes. Piles can be added beside failing footings to re-support a sagging or heaving deck without tearing it down, depending on access and framing.

Do helical piles need a permit in Toronto?

The footing type doesn’t change whether the deck needs a permit. If your deck needs a permit, the footings are part of it. We provide the pile documentation your application needs.

Can helical piles be installed in winter?

Yes, in most conditions. Unlike concrete, piles don’t need to cure, so cold weather doesn’t stop the job unless the ground is frozen very hard or the site is unsafe.

Will helical piles damage my lawn?

Damage is minimal compared to digging. There are no spoil piles, and the compact machines leave a much smaller footprint than excavating for concrete.

Are helical piles good for a hot tub deck?

Yes. Hot tubs add a heavy, concentrated load, and piles can be sized and spaced for it. Let us know about the hot tub at the planning stage.

Get the right footing for your deck

Citywide Post Hole Digging installs both helical piles and concrete deck footings across Toronto and the GTA, so our recommendation is based on your site, not on what we happen to sell. If you’re planning a new deck, a full deck build or a sunroom or addition, we’ll look at your soil, access and design and tell you which footing makes sense.

Call 416-721-9971 or contact us for a free site assessment.